Five Ways to Differentiate: Product, Service, Channel, People and Image

Differentiation is the D in the STDP process. Once we have segmented the market and chosen a target market, we need to decide how our offer will be different from the competition. Only then can we position it.

The standard marketing textbooks, led by Kotler and Armstrong’s Principles of Marketing, group the ways a firm can differentiate into five types: product, services, channel, people and image. In this post we will work through each one using the same example, a small coffee shop, and then look at how to choose which differences are worth building a position around.

What do we mean by differentiation?

Differentiation means making our offer different from competing offers in a way that the target market values. That last part matters. A difference that customers don’t notice, or don’t care about, doesn’t really count.

So differentiation is not the same as being unusual. A coffee shop could paint its walls bright green and play polka music all day. That is certainly different. But would it make the target market more likely to buy? Probably not.

It is also worth separating two terms that students often mix up. Differentiated marketing is a targeting strategy, where a firm goes after several segments with a different offer for each. Differentiation, the topic here, is about how one offer stands apart from its competitors. A firm with a single target market still needs differentiation.

Our example: two coffee shops on one street

Imagine Marco runs a small coffee shop on a busy street near a university. Two doors down is a branch of a large coffee chain. The chain has a bigger marketing budget, a well-known name and a loyalty app.

Marco has decided that his target market is students and staff from the university who want somewhere to sit and work for an hour or two. So the question becomes: why should those people walk past the chain and come into Marco’s shop? Let’s look at the five options.

1. Product differentiation

Product differentiation is about the physical product itself. Features, performance, quality, consistency, style and design all fit here.

For Marco, this could mean coffee from a local roaster, a house blend that the chain doesn’t offer, or a short menu of food baked on the premises each morning. It could also mean simple things done well, like coffee that is the right temperature every time.

Product differences are often the first thing a business thinks of. But they can be the easiest for a competitor to copy. If Marco’s oat milk flat white becomes popular, how long would it take the chain to add something similar? Not long.

That doesn’t make product differentiation useless. It just means it often works best when it is combined with one of the other types.

2. Services differentiation

Services differentiation is about everything that surrounds the product. Textbooks usually list things like ordering ease, speed and convenience of delivery, installation, customer training, advice and repairs. Not all of these apply to every business, of course. Nobody needs their coffee installed.

For a coffee shop, service differences could include:

  • table service, so customers don’t lose their seat while queuing
  • remembering a regular’s usual order
  • free refills of filter coffee for people who stay a while
  • being able to order ahead and collect without waiting
  • power points at every table and Wi-Fi that actually works

Look at Marco’s target market again. Students who want to sit and work probably care more about the power points and refills than about a slightly better bean. So service may be a stronger basis for Marco than product.

3. Channel differentiation

Channel differentiation comes from how the product reaches the customer. That covers how many places it is available (coverage), how much expertise sits in the channel, and how well the channel performs.

For a large business, this might be the difference between selling through a few specialist stores or through every supermarket. For Marco it is more modest, but there are still choices. He could open a small kiosk inside the university library. He could deliver coffee orders to staff meetings on campus. He could sell bags of his house blend through the campus store.

Each of those makes Marco’s coffee easier to get than the chain’s for his particular target market. And notice that the product hasn’t changed at all. Only the route to the customer has.

4. People differentiation

People differentiation means gaining an advantage by hiring and training better staff than the competition. Friendly, knowledgeable, reliable and responsive staff can be a real point of difference, especially in services, where the employee is often part of what the customer is buying.

In a coffee shop, this is very visible. Customers notice whether the barista knows how to make a good coffee, whether they are greeted when they walk in, and whether a problem gets fixed without fuss.

Why might this suit Marco? Because a large chain with high staff turnover may find it hard to match. If Marco keeps the same staff for years, and they know the regulars by name, that is a difference that is difficult to copy quickly.

But it is also fragile. If Marco’s best barista leaves, part of the difference may walk out the door with them.

5. Image differentiation

Image differentiation is about how the brand is seen. Even when two offers are quite similar, customers may see them differently because of the brand’s name, logo, symbols, atmosphere and the events it is associated with.

For Marco, image could come from the shop’s fit-out, the music, the art on the walls by local students, or hosting an open mic night once a month. Over time, his shop might come to be seen as the independent, local place where people from the university go, while the chain is seen as the quick, predictable option.

Image takes time to build, and it has to match what customers actually experience. There is little point in Marco calling his shop “the friendliest café on campus” if the service is slow and the staff are grumpy. The image has to be backed up by the other four types.

Which differences should we promote?

By now Marco has a long list of possible differences. He can’t promote them all. If he tries, his message will be confusing and he will spend money on things customers don’t value.

Kotler and Armstrong suggest that a difference is worth establishing when it is:

  • Important: it delivers a benefit the target market values.
  • Distinctive: competitors don’t offer it, or Marco offers it in a clearly different way.
  • Superior: it is better than other ways customers could get the same benefit.
  • Communicable: customers can see it and it can be explained to them.
  • Preemptive: competitors can’t easily copy it.
  • Affordable: the target market can afford to pay for it.
  • Profitable: the business can make money from it.

Let’s test one of Marco’s ideas. Free filter coffee refills are important to students who stay for a while, and they are communicable (a sign on the counter does the job). Are they preemptive? Not really, as the chain could match it. Are they profitable? Maybe, if refill customers also buy food, but Marco would need to watch that.

Now test the combination of long-serving staff, a relaxed place to work and a kiosk in the library. That is harder for the chain to copy, and it fits the target market closely. It is probably a better basis for Marco’s position than any single product feature.

From differentiation to positioning

Once Marco has chosen his main differences, he can turn them into a position. That is where the positioning step of STDP takes over.

A useful way to frame this is with points-of-difference and points-of-parity. Marco’s points of difference might be the staff and the space to work. His points of parity are the things he simply has to match, such as decent coffee and reasonable prices. If he falls short on those, the points of difference won’t save him.

Differentiation also has to carry through the whole marketing mix. If Marco’s difference is a relaxed place to work, then his opening hours, seating, pricing and promotion all need to support it.

A quick exercise

Pick a business near you that competes with a much larger brand. It could be a bookshop, a gym, a hairdresser or a bakery. Go through the five types and ask:

  • How does it differ in product, service, channel, people and image?
  • Which of those differences does its target market actually care about?
  • Which ones could the larger competitor copy within a few months?

You will often find that the strongest differences for a small business are not in the product at all. They are in the service, the people and the image.

Sources
Scroll to Top